Jeter

on a hard hit grounder that should have been caught routinely, Jeter dove and then threw the ball away (while on his knees). he was not credited with an error, even though two runners scored on the play.

I don't know the official scoring rules, but shouldn't the play be constantly re-evaluated depending on the situation? In other words, Jeter even if you assume jeter made a "great" play to get to the ball, that shouldn't negate anything he does after it. He threw the ball away. The runner from second scored b/c of that throw.

That was an error, even if it was Jeter doing it.